In folk music there has always been a tradition of memorializing sensational events such as mining disasters, murders, and train wrecks in song, and the April 14-15, 1912 wreck of SS TITANIC was no exception. Within a few years of the tragedy, songwriters were making up and singing lyrics about it.
According to Newman I. White's 1928 publication AMERICAN NEGRO FOLKSONGS, the earliest lyrics about TITANIC were sung as early as 1915 or 1916 by black singers living in the Hackleburg, Alabama area. A later writer, Jeff Place, would comment in notes he contributed to THE AMERICAN ANTHOLOGY OF FOLK MUSIC that African Americans found it "noteworthy and ironic" that company policies of the White Star Line, the owners of TITANIC, kept people of color from sailing aboard her, and some attributed her sinking to divine retribution in consequence. This may account for these lyrics, some variant of which may be found in most versions: "But the Lord's almighty hand said this ship would never land/Oh it was sad when the great ship went down!"
The great North Carolina folklorist Frank C. Brown collected a variant in the mountains around 1920. However, the next fairly well-known version of the song was written, according to his Wikipedia biography, by Ernest V. "Pop" Stoneman (1893-1968) in 1924. Pop Stoneman is better remembered nowadays as the father of fourteen children, some of whom became professional musicians themselves (the most famous being banjo-playing Roni, a member of the cast of HEE HAW for many years), but he was in his day quite a well-known singer and songwriter and arranger. Pop recorded his original version of "The Sinking of the TITANIC" for Edison Recordings in 1928. In the Wikipedia article, this song is said to be country music's first million selling record--a matter of some dispute, since the same is said of 1924's "The Prisoner's Song", recorded by light opera singer Marion Try Slaughter under the pseudonym Vernon Dalhart. Dalhart himself recorded a version of one TITANIC variant in the 1920s, under the title "The TITANIC (It Was Sad When that Great Ship Went Down)".
That line "it was sad when that great ship went down" appears in nearly all variants of the ballad. It's certainly a feature of the one recorded in the 1950s by Roy Claxton Acuff (1903-1992), the "King of Country Music." Roy Acuff had begun his career as a country singer in the 1930s, when a sunstroke followed by a nervous breakdown put paid to his dreams of a career in professional baseball. It was the sudden realization of the approaching anniversary of the sinking that reminded me of Mr. Roy's version of the song, sung in that mournful, full-out, often clueless as to key, but nonetheless beloved and distinctive voice of his. It's been playing on the soundtrack in my head for days now.
Mr. Roy's version is, at three verses and choruses, considerably shorter than others on the same theme, but it hits the high points about Monday morning ("about one o'clock") when the ship sank, about the retribution of God, and about the rich refusing to get into the lifeboats with the poor--although there is some reason to think this last may have had less to do with class distinctions than with fears that people trying to heave themselves out of the icy Atlantic waters into the lifeboats would capsize them. And, of course, there is this sentiment: "it was sad when that great ship went down."
It's a bit of a relief to turn to a somewhat lighter treatment of the sinking of TITANIC. The great North Carolina singer and guitarist Arthel "Doc" Watson recorded a song called "Travelin' Man" on his 1967 album BALLADS FROM DEEP GAP that tells a story of a hobo and gambler named Joe who, among other feats, just misses disaster on TITANIC, escaping her fate through superhuman powers:
Joe hoboed the great TITANIC, thought he'd try out the ocean blue,
When he seen that ol' iceberg comin', right off of that boat he flew!
All of them passengers hollered and laughed and said look at what a great big fool,
But while that ol' boat was sinkin' Joe was shootin' craps in Liverpool.
For more information about these songs and singers, check out their Wikipedia sites. The keywords "it was sad when that great ship went down" brings up nearly all of the song variants, while the names of the singers/songwriters bring up their biographies.
And yes, it IS still sad that that great ship went down. It has, however, become less of a tragedy that actually happened, I think, than a metaphor for any doomed enterprise that has the word "hubris" attached to it. Some have even applied it to the current Bush presidency; I'll leave it up to historians whether that's a premature designation or not.
And until next time, fair thee well.